Are Heated Eyelash Curlers Better Than Normal Ones? (Revealed)

Please note: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Details here.

Look…

When it comes to achieving perfectly curled lashes, the beauty industry offers the traditional mechanical curlers that have been around for decades and their newer, tech-savvy counterparts – electric eyelash heated curlers.

You’ve likely stood in the beauty aisle contemplating which to choose.

So, beneath the marketing claims and beauty influencer recommendations, which type truly delivers better results for your specific lashes?

Are heated eyelash curlers better than normal ones?

Let’s find out.

How Eyelash Curlers Have Evolved Through the Years

First, I want to touch on the history and how this beauty accessory has evolved over the years.

Let’s face it, the eyelash curler isn’t a recent invention.

They have evolved significantly since the first patented design in 1931.

Traditional mechanical curlers remained largely unchanged for decades until heated options emerged in the early 2000s, offering a technological alternative to the classic design that had dominated the beauty industry.

Traditional Curlers: The Mechanical Approach

Traditional eyelash curlers rely on a simple mechanical principle – pressure.

The metal frame features a curved clamp that, when pressed against the rubber pad, physically bends your lashes upward.

This immediate crimping action creates an instant lift that forms the foundation for your mascara application.

Most conventional curlers share common design elements:

• A scissor-like handle for grip and control
• A spring mechanism that regulates pressure
• A curved metal frame designed to match the eye’s curvature
• A replaceable rubber pad that cushions lashes during clamping

The beauty of traditional curlers lies in their simplicity, in a sense that they require no batteries, no warm-up time, and deliver immediate results.

With proper technique, they can dramatically open up the eye area in seconds.

Heated Curlers: Adding Temperature to the Equation

Now…

Heated eyelash curlers work on the same principle as most hair styling tools, specifically using gentle heat to temporarily reshape the protein structure in your lashes.

The heat allows the curl to form more gradually and often results in a longer-lasting effect.

There are two primary types of heated eyelash curlers:

• Wand-style heated curlers: Resembling mascara wands with heated comb-like teeth that you brush through your lashes
• Clamp-style heated curlers: Similar in design to traditional curlers but with heating elements built into the curling mechanism

Most heated curlers operate at temperatures between 100-140°F (38-60°C), which is warm enough to reshape lashes but significantly cooler than hair styling tools to prevent damage to the delicate eye area.

Next.

Comparison Video Between the Two

Here’s a comparison video and whether the new fancy technology really works:

Products to check out:

• Best heated eyelash curlers
• Surratt Relevee Lash Curler
• Shiseido Eyelash Curler

In the next couple of sections I’ll discuss the reasons why people choose one type or the other.

Reasons to Buy Heated Eyelash Curlers

Look…

There are a few benefits to using this type of products, which I’d like to talk about next.

(With some comments from renowned make up artists in favor of eyelash heated curlers.)

Longer-Lasting Curl Retention

The most significant advantage heated curlers offer is longevity.

A 2019 independent beauty study found that curls created with heated tools lasted an average of 6-8 hours, while traditional curlers began losing their effect after 3-4 hours, particularly in humid environments.

This extended hold comes from the same scientific principle behind heated hair tools.

The gentle heat temporarily alters the hydrogen bonds in the keratin structure of your lashes, allowing them to reform in the new curled position as they cool.

This creates a more stable curl that can withstand environmental factors better than a mechanical crimp alone.

For special occasions, photoshoots, or long workdays where touch-ups aren’t possible, this staying power gives heated curlers a distinct advantage.

More Natural-Looking Results

One common complaint about traditional curlers is the sometimes artificial-looking “crimped” effect they create, specifically a visible bend where the clamp pressed against the lashes.

This L-shaped curl can look unnatural, especially when viewed from the side.

Heated curlers, particularly wand styles, tend to create a more gradual C-shaped curl that mimics naturally curly lashes.

This gentle curve opens the eye more effectively while looking more natural.

Here’s what celebrity makeup artist Hannah Martin, who has worked with members of the British royal family, shares:

“Heated curlers create that beautiful, soft C-shaped curve rather than the sharp angle you sometimes get with traditional curlers. It’s that subtle difference that makes lashes look naturally curled rather than artificially crimped.”

Most ladies would prefer to look natural, so that’s a huge plus!

Better Results for Stubborn Lash Types

If you have naturally straight, downward-pointing, or particularly resistant lashes, heated curlers often provide superior results.

The heat element helps overcome the natural resistance of certain lash types that simply bounce back to their original position after mechanical curling.

This benefit is particularly noticeable for:

• Thick, coarse lashes that resist traditional curling
• Very straight, downward-pointing lashes common in Asian eye shapes
• Naturally stiff lashes that quickly lose their curl with mechanical curlers

Here’s what makeup artist Nam Vo shares, who is known for her work with clients who have diverse eye shapes and lash types:

“For my clients with stubborn straight lashes that resist traditional curling, heated curlers have been game-changing. The heat component helps ‘train’ the lashes to hold the curl far longer than pressure alone.”

Pretty awesome, right?

Gentler Application Process

Now…

While “heat” and “gentle” might seem contradictory, properly designed heated curlers can actually be less traumatic to lashes than mechanical ones.

Traditional curlers exert significant pressure to create an instant crimp, which can sometimes cause lash breakage or pulling, especially if you’re not careful with placement.

Heated curlers, particularly wand styles, curl with minimal pressure.

The gradual heating action means they don’t require the forceful crimping that can stress or break lashes. For those with fragile or sparse lashes, this gentler approach can be beneficial for lash health over time.

The Case for Regular Eyelash Curlers

In order for this post to be objective, I also want to make the case for normal type of curlers that we’ve all likely used for years.

Reliability and Consistency

Despite technological advances, traditional eyelash curlers remain bestsellers for good reason – they work reliably every time.

With no batteries to die, no heating element to malfunction, and no warm-up time required, mechanical curlers offer immediate and consistent results.

This reliability makes them particularly valuable when:

• You’re in a hurry and need immediate results
• You’re concerned about consistent performance over time
• You’re traveling and don’t want to worry about charging devices

A quality traditional curler from brands like Shu Uemura or Kevyn Aucoin will deliver predictable results for years with only occasional pad replacements needed.

Zero Risk of Heat Damage

The most significant advantage of traditional curlers is the complete absence of heat damage risk.

While properly used heated curlers operate at safe temperatures, there’s still always a small possibility of:

• Overheating due to product malfunction
• User error leading to excessive heat exposure
• Cumulative heat damage from frequent use over time

For those with particularly delicate or damaged lashes, or anyone concerned about the potential long-term effects of heat styling, traditional curlers offer peace of mind that no heat damage can occur.

Cost-Effectiveness and Longevity

From a practical standpoint, traditional eyelash curlers are a more economical option.

A high-quality mechanical curler typically costs between $15-30 and can last for years with occasional rubber pad replacements (which typically cost under $5).

The best heated eyelash curlers generally start at $30 for basic models and can run up to $100 for premium versions.

They also have limited lifespans due to battery degradation and heating element wear, typically requiring replacement every 1-2 years with regular use.

This significant cost difference makes traditional curlers the economical choice, especially for those who aren’t convinced they need the additional benefits of heated options.

Better for Beginners and Everyday Use

For those new to lash curling, traditional curlers offer a straightforward learning curve.

The immediate visual feedback (you see the curl instantly) helps users understand proper placement and pressure. The simplicity of use (like position, squeeze, release) makes them accessible even to makeup novices.

Makeup artist Lisa Eldridge notes:

“For beginners, I always recommend starting with a traditional curler to master the basic technique and understand how curling changes your eye appearance. Once you’re comfortable with that, then explore whether heated options might enhance your results.”

Makes sense, right?

Next…

Choosing the Right One for Your Specific Needs

Alright, now that we’ve made the case for both types, how do you choose the right product that fits YOUR needs?

I’d divide it into 2 categories, your lash type and your lifestyle.

Let’s discuss.

Assessing Your Natural Lash Type

Your natural lashes should be the primary consideration when choosing between heated and traditional curlers:

• Straight, resistant lashes

If your lashes naturally point straight out or downward and resist curling, heated options will likely provide better, longer-lasting results.

• Already somewhat curly lashes

If you have naturally lifted lashes that just need enhancement, traditional curlers typically provide sufficient curl without the additional heat element.

• Fine or sparse lashes

Those with delicate or fewer lashes might benefit from the gentler approach of heated wand-style curlers that don’t compress lashes between metal components.

• Very short lashes

Traditional curlers can sometimes struggle to grab very short lashes, while some heated wand designs can engage even shorter lashes effectively.

Considering Your Environment and Lifestyle

Your daily environment plays a surprising role in curler performance:

• Humid climate

If you live in a high-humidity area like Florida or Hawaii, heated curlers generally maintain curl better against moisture that can cause traditional curls to drop.

• Active lifestyle

For those who exercise regularly or work in high-energy environments where sweating occurs, heated curling typically withstands physical activity better.

• Frequent travel

Traditional curlers require no charging, batteries, or adapters, making them more convenient for travelers crossing different electrical standards.

• Time constraints

If your morning routine is rushed, traditional curlers provide immediate results without warm-up time.

What Curlers Do Professional Makeup Artists Use?

Next…

I spoke with and researched several professional makeup artists who work across editorial, celebrity, and bridal industries to get their perspective on the heated versus traditional debate.

Patrick Ta, who works with celebrities like Gigi Hadid and Shay Mitchell, says the following:

“The best eyelash curler isn’t universal – it’s the one that works with your unique eye shape, lash type, and lifestyle needs. What works perfectly for your friend might be completely wrong for you.”

Makeup artist Katie Jane Hughes, known for her editorial work with major beauty brands, shared:

“I keep both in my kit because different situations call for different tools. For quick everyday looks, I use traditional. For photoshoots where the curl needs to hold for hours under hot lights, I almost always reach for heated.”

And Nick Barose, who works with celebrities like Lupita Nyong’o, offered this perspective:

“It’s not about which is better overall. It’s understanding which is better for your specific client’s needs. I find heated curlers excel with straight, stubborn Asian lashes, while traditional curlers offer reliability and speed when I’m working backstage at fashion shows.”

The consensus among professionals seems to be that both tools have their place, with heated curlers excelling in specific situations rather than being universally superior.

Some makeup experts and enthusiasts combine traditional and heated methods for optimal results.

The most effective hybrid technique is the Two-Step Method.

Basically, first you use a traditional curler to create the initial shape, then follow with a heated curler to “set” the curl for longevity, effectively combining the precise curl placement of regular curlers with the staying power of heated tools.

If you’re still undecided, check out the next paragraph.

Making Your Decision: Questions to Consider

If you’re still weighing heated versus traditional options, ask yourself:

1. Does your curl typically drop within hours? If your lashes lose their curl quickly, a heated option might be worth the investment.
2. Do you have straight, downward-pointing lashes? Heated curlers typically perform better for naturally straight or stubborn lashes.
3. How much time do you have for your morning routine? Traditional curlers offer immediate results without warm-up time.
4. Do you travel frequently? Traditional curlers require no charging and work internationally without adapters.
5. How concerned are you about potential heat damage? If you have fragile lashes or concerns about heat styling, regular ones eliminate this risk entirely.
6. What’s your budget? Traditional curlers represent a more economical long-term investment, while heated options involve higher initial costs and eventual replacement.
7. Are you environmentally conscious? Heated options contain electronic components and batteries that eventually contribute to electronic waste, making them a less sustainable choice for eco-minded consumers.

Asking these questions should help in making an educated buying decision!

My Final Thoughts

So…

Are heated eyelash curlers better than normal ones?

Like with many things, the answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. Rather, the “better” curler depends entirely on your unique lash type, lifestyle needs, and personal preferences.

Heated eyelash curlers excel in creating longer-lasting curls that stand up to humidity and time.

They’re particularly valuable for those with naturally straight, resistant lashes or for occasions where longevity matters.

The gentler curling action also produces more natural-looking results without the crimped effect sometimes seen with mechanical curlers.

Traditional eyelash curlers continue to earn their place in makeup kits worldwide with their reliability, immediate results, and freedom from charging or battery concerns.

They completely eliminate heat damage risk and represent a more economical option that can last for years with minimal maintenance.

Many professional makeup artists maintain both tools in their kits, recognizing that different situations call for different approaches.

For everyday consumers, the choice should reflect your specific lash challenges, typical environment, and comfort level with the technology.

Ultimately, the most important factor isn’t whether you choose heated or traditional, but rather that you select a quality option appropriate for your eye shape and use it with proper technique.

When used correctly, either style can dramatically enhance your eyes and elevate your overall makeup look, which is the true measure of any beauty tool’s success.

What matters most is finding the tool that makes you feel confident in your beauty routine.

Also, you can check out our battery powered clothing reviews and heated home products on our website.

Now I’d like to hear from you:

• Have you tried both types of eyelash curlers?
• Which one works better with your unique lash type?

Share your thoughts in the comments below!